The Digital Inclusion Hustings – five questions for our next Prime Minister

Conservative Party members are, as we speak, deciding who will be the next Prime Minister. And whilst most will have already decided, I know others are still waiting to hear how the two candidates – Boris Johnson and Jeremy Hunt – respond on some key issues. While Brexit is the topic that is of course getting the most attention, there are many other important issues for our new Prime Minister – and I happen to think that digital inclusion is an important one. So, I’m writing this blog – sending it to both candidates – as I want to put a series of questions to them on how they plan to tackle an issue which could see the UK being left behind as the world becomes increasingly digital. So…

Dear Mr Johnson and Mr Hunt,

I want to ask you both what you would do, if Prime Minister, to address the digital inequalities in the UK. Although Mr Johnson you have committed to deliver better, faster broadband at an accelerated pace, there is also a deep divide between those who have the digital skills and confidence to benefit fully, and those who do not. The latest Ofcom release shows a 17% gap in internet use between adults in high and low socio-economic groups. Of people with zero digital skills, 46% earn less than £17,499 a year, and people with basic digital skills can expect a lifetime increase of their average earnings of 2.8%. 

There are 11.9 million people in the UK who still don’t have essential digital skills; and our research shows that, at current rates of progress, by 2028 there will still be 6.9 million people in the UK – 12% of the population – without these skills. These are the questions we think you need to answer. 

1) At Good Things Foundation, we calculated last year that if everyone in the UK had digital skills, it would offer a net present value of £21.9 billion to the UK economy. Would you commit to a 100% fully digitally included UK and how would you do it? (And, Mr Johnson and Mr Hunt, if you’re stuck for ideas – have a look at our Blueprint for a 100% Digitally Included Nation).

2) How will you support microbusinesses and sole traders who are struggling to reap the benefits of digital? For example, one quarter of micro businesses used none of the seven technologies identified as most relevant, and a similar proportion used only one digital technology. The UK e-commerce survey found that only 8.8% of micro businesses were making website sales compared to 46% of large businesses. The microbusiness owners and sole traders we spoke to in Powering Up: How more people, communities and businesses can participate in a digital economy told us that they face factors like not having the time to learn new skills and the amount it would cost to be suitably trained means that many find it impossible to keep up with bigger, more digitally able firms. 

3) How will your government alleviate the fears of non-internet users to ensure that the internet is a safe place to be, especially when performing financial transactions online and avoiding the harms the internet can present? I have previously discussed avenues of opportunity that the current Online Harms White Paper offers for digital inclusion. One in five non-internet users don’t go online because they don’t trust the internet, or don’t feel it’s online or secure. 

4) How will you support people to get the digital skills they need to get by in the modern economy? People will need to get by at work: we need to talk about how the future of work and automation of jobs will affect people who currently do not possess the basic skills they need at work and to apply for jobs. People will also need to get by in life: a ‘digital first’ approach (which I support) saves Government money and is more convenient for those who can interact with the state online, however more needs to be done to ensure everyone can benefit. Good Things Foundation is offering digital assistance for the 2021 Census and with HMCTS services; yet schemes like Universal Credit has a ‘digital first’ approach and offers no official government digital assistance. However, many who are eligible for Universal Credit do not have the digital skills to apply online. Our plan will help you to seize the economic and social benefits of a fully digitally included nation.

5) Finally, we found in our above mentioned Powering Up report that we can only really tackle digital exclusion by all sectors; private, public and third sector, working together. How will your government link up people, companies and organisations, to ensure that digital exclusion is tackled? A Good example of schemes of this nature is Power Up, which Good Things Foundation are doing in collaboration with J.P. Morgan and SCVO.

Mr Hunt and Mr Johnson, Please feel free to send your response to helen@goodthingsfoundation.org and we will, of course, publish them immediately!

Healthier citizens: nobody left behind in a digital society

Often when I’m describing our work at Good Things Foundation I talk about us being the glue in the system – acting as the link between national Governments and senior people in big, often global, corporations, and our networks of small, local community based partners. A great example of this is supporting people to use digital, which leads to them being healthier – working with national governments and community organisations to make real change happen. In England, we’re in our seventh year of working in this way, and in Australia this is our first year of thinking and working to blend digital inclusion (or digital literacy) and digital health literacy – building on our successes. And in Wales, we’ve just this week embarked on a new 3 year partnership supporting Wales Co-operative Centre to deliver the Welsh Government’s new programme on boosting people’s digital confidence, health and wellbeing. Exciting times!

Digital and community have been the cornerstones of our approach for over a decade. We believe in a world where everyone benefits from digital, so it’s not surprising this is central to the work we do. Our work spans a continuum from deep reach and impact – building new relationships, and changing systems – through to lighter touch engagement, which involves introducing people to digital health resources as part of their digital skills journey. And all of this is done with our movement of community-based organisations across both the UK and Australia who tailor support based on the needs of the people they’re helping. So it makes sense that community is one of the key ways to overcome the inequality digital can drive in our society. Digital exclusion is exacerbating social exclusion, but it can also drive inclusion too – and that is what we are trying to do, working with our partners both big and global, and, small and local.

In the UK, people who are digitally excluded (eg with no or low digital skills) are more likely to be older and/or experiencing social exclusion. You are three times more likely to be offline if you live on a lower income (‘DE household’) than if you live in a higher income household (Ofcom 2019). So while we deliver support around inclusion and digital literacy, this is done through different lenses – such as employability, financial resilience, and health – so we are not only improving people’s digital skills, but helping them to overcome a range of issues, from loneliness through to mental health issues, poverty and unemployment. We’re stopping people from becoming even more excluded. By leveraging the power of both digital and community, we can help people tackle some of the challenges they face, such as preventing illness and taking charge of their own health.

We’ve learned so much over the years, but two key things I’d like to talk about are how improved digital health literacy can drive better health outcomes, and how relationships between the NHS and those in the community help us to affect change.

Improved digital health literacy drives better health outcomes

Technology is revolutionising the way that healthcare is delivered around the world. Apps are making it easy for us to track our weight, food intake and exercise – as well as to manage long term conditions, or to connect with peers.

There is no doubt that digital technology offers huge opportunities to improve health and healthcare. But we can’t leave anyone behind. Everyone must have the choice to get the support and skills they need to use fast, efficient, well designed, convenient, flexible digital health tools and apps.

Digital health literacy has to be the next step from basic digital literacy. There are 11.9 million people in the UK who do not have all the essential digital skills for life (Lloyds CDI 2019), and an estimated 7 million people in Australia – and this means they’re not able to search for information, fill out a form, or send an email. These people are more likely to be older, poorer and living with disabilities, to be at risk of conditions like type 2 diabetes, depression and anxiety, and so it follows that they’re more likely to need health services and support.

We want people to have digital skills so that they can have better lives. We want people to have basic digital health literacy so they can have better health. And this also means that they’ll have equality of access to great digital tools – the NHS App in England, or My Health Record in Australia.

And improved digital health skills don’t just mean people can use apps to manage their health. With improved digital literacy, through the support of hyperlocal community venues, people feel not just digitally able but empowered too. This leads to people improving their health, like Simon who has lost weight and reduced his blood sugar level by developing his digital confidence after being diagnosed with type 2 diabetes. People are able to manage their conditions better online, and to take important steps that will improve their health in the long term.

The large overlap between people who are digitally and socially excluded, and between social exclusion and the drivers of health inequality, means that action on digital literacy can help drive better health outcomes – and, equally significantly, can help to prevent existing health inequalities from widening further.

Local + Scale: Improving people’s health

In England, over the last two years we’ve moved from a hyperlocal focus on people and the community outside the formal NHS, to creating evidence on new ways of enabling some of the most excluded groups in our society to benefit from digital health resources. We’re doing this through supporting 20 innovative pathfinders across England, focussing on a range of audience groups and health conditions.

We supported Nailsea Town Council to bring digital health to the high street, developing a high street digital health hub which connected people with each other and with the digital resources they need to live well. One man living with dementia was able to learn how to use Skype to communicate with his family. As he was able to read visual signs, this was a much more successful way of communicating.

We investigated socially prescribing digital skills in Sheffield and worked with Dr Ollie Hart and the Sloan Medical Centre to answer the question: Can the introduction of digital within social prescribing help people to take more ownership of their health and wellbeing? That’s where Simon – the case study above – was supported, and this ‘social prescribing’ model is persisting beyond the pathfinder and is now spreading further.

And In Hastings, we worked with the Seaview Project and their partners to enable people who are sleeping rough to access the health services and information they need – resulting in a whole range of positive results which will have a preventative impact in the long term, including improving eating habits to help prevent diabetes to learning how to take blood pressure medication correctly.

These Pathfinder projects – as well as our wider work in digital and social inclusion – have taught us some important things. To fully harness the potential of a ‘digital first’ health services for the most socially and digitally excluded people in our society, we need to remove the significant barriers that exist for people in a person-centred, community-based way – using trusted relationships especially between people working in the community (community centre staff or volunteers) and the people working in the formal health service (GPs, health visitors, paramedics, et al).

We are now spreading and scaling this hyperlocal digital health hub model in five more local health and care systems across England: North West London, Liverpool, Middlesbrough, Staffordshire, and Blackburn. We’re doing this so we can stress test what we’ve learned, to see if our model can be replicated and scaled up further.

Just this week we’ve launched a new grant funding round in England to see how far we can continue to scale – funding mini Digital Health Hubs with a focus on building or enhancing those all-important trusted relationships especially between local people and those working in the health service. Building these relationships is so important – I think of these Digital Health Hubs as being the bridge that makes these bonds stronger and lead people to have better health.

Now that Good Things is global – working in the UK and Australia – we’re hoping to spread this knowledge and commitment to digital skills and improving health. In Australia, we know the demand is there from our network partners – with 70% of them saying they were already blending digital literacy and digital health literacy or that they were very interested in doing so. We’re really keen to help them with this.

It’s never been a hard ‘sell’ to convince people that they want to apply their newly learned basic digital skills to accessing better health services. Everyone gets ill, everyone has loved ones who get ill – it’s universal.

It’s so important that, as digital health services take off and really deliver better and more personalised services, we work harder to ensure that nobody is left behind.

All the findings mentioned here are available online: for the first phase of our NHS Widening Digital Participation Programme (2013-2016) and for our second phase (2017-2020) on our Digital Health Lab site.